First-time buyers

At today's rates, buying beats renting in just 1 of 10 big cities

A first-time buyer with a 10% deposit faces mortgage rates of about 6%. At that rate, the monthly repayment on a typical home is below the average rent only in Newcastle upon Tyne, though a flat costs less to buy than to rent in half of the cities.

Average monthly private rent against the repayment on the median home, at 6.04% and 4.63%, in the 10 largest cities

Newcastle is the exception

Take a couple renting in Newcastle upon Tyne for the average of about £1,200 a month (August 2026). Buying a typical home, at about £200,000, would cost them about £30 a month less.

Saving the deposit is the harder part. Ten per cent of that home is about £20,000, or about seven months' pay before tax for a typical full-time worker in the city.

The 6% is Moneyfacts' average five-year fix for a buyer with a 10% deposit in October 2026, up from 5.7% in September (Moneyfacts, 19 October 2026).

Leicester, Sheffield and London: the widest gaps

Leicester has the widest gap outside London. Buying a typical home there costs about £400 a month more than renting. Sheffield comes next, at about £340.

In Leicester the repayment would take just over half of a typical full-time worker's monthly pay before tax. The rent takes under two fifths.

In London a typical home sold for about £525,000, and the repayment comes to about £730 a month more than the average rent. The deposit alone, about £53,000, is more than a year's pay before tax for a typical full-time London worker.

No London borough is cheaper to buy. Tower Hamlets is closest, at about £380 a month more.

A lower rate changes the picture

Not every borrower pays 6%. Across all new mortgages, the average rate was 4.63% in September 2026 (Bank of England, 29 October 2026).

At that rate, buying also comes out cheaper in Bristol and Manchester, and Nottingham is level. Newcastle's saving grows to nearly £190 a month. Treat it as a best case: the average includes buyers with big deposits.

Flats: cheaper to buy in half the cities

The typical home sold is usually a house; many renters live in flats. Comparing flat with flat at 6%, buying costs less a month in Newcastle, Leicester, Birmingham, Nottingham and Leeds.

The saving is small, from about £30 to £100 a month. In London a flat still costs about £450 a month more to buy.

Rents are still rising, by 3.8% across the UK in the year to September 2026, while London house prices fell over the year to August, led by flats (ONS, 21 October 2026).

What this means for you

How we did this

We took the median price of every home sold from June 2025 to May 2026 (HM Land Registry, category B sales left out), by 2023 local authority; London is its 33 local authorities. "Typical" means this median. Later months are left out as many sales are still being registered. The repayment is on 90% of that price over 25 years at 6.04% (Moneyfacts' average 90% loan-to-value five-year fix, October 2026) and 4.63% (Bank of England). Rents are ONS's average (mean) for all private lets in August 2026, sitting tenants included, so they are below asking rents on new lets.

Pay is ONS's median gross annual pay of full-time employees living in each city (2025; London as a region).

The comparison leaves out stamp duty, fees, service charges, maintenance and the interest a deposit could earn, and holds the rate for 25 years. Shared ownership part shares are counted as sales. England & Wales only.

Check your area

See sale prices and rents for your own area on the map at trackmystreet.com/uk.

Data

  • Price paid data, Jun 2025 to May 2026: HM Land Registry (Open Government Licence v3.0)
  • Price Index of Private Rents, Aug 2026: Office for National Statistics (Open Government Licence v3.0)
  • Average 90% LTV five-year fixed rate, Oct 2026: Moneyfacts
  • Effective rate on newly drawn mortgages, Sep 2026: Bank of England
  • Annual Survey of Hours and Earnings, 2025: Office for National Statistics (Open Government Licence v3.0)

Changes to this article

  • 2026-11: first published.
  • 2026-11: rewritten for readability, with comparisons to local pay.